Security or Exclusion? The Problem with Confusing CAPTCHAs
Tried to submit a complaint on Royal Mail’s website today and got stuck at the CAPTCHA.
“Click the incomplete tower.” None of the towers were incomplete. They were just different heights.
“Identify the icon that does not follow the pattern.” In one row, a single character was a slightly lighter blue than the rest. Easy enough. But in another row, there was a turquoise character, an orange one and two yellow ones. If colour is the pattern, that row breaks it three times over.
I work in IT and use computers every day, and I still found these confusing. Now imagine someone older, less confident with technology, or living with a visual or cognitive impairment. For them, this isn’t a minor annoyance. It’s a locked door between them and a public service.
These are hCaptcha puzzles, built to stop bots. But a test that real people can’t understand isn’t security; it’s exclusion. Organisations choosing these tools need to think about who they’re shutting out.